Two slices and a soda for only $9.99!? Yes please! Thin NY style crust is the best! Great customer service! Relaxing vibes. And they have Schweppes Ginger Ale on tap!!

Excellent pizza!! I'm pretty new to the area and I had been looking for a good pizza place. I will look no further, this place is it! Ordered the XXL pepperoni and it was absolutely fantastic! Nice and thin, had great crunch.....delicious. Not sure how well the pizza holds up if you carry out but having it in their dining room was just great. Super friendly staff and excellent service. Cant wait till the next time we come in. Keep up the amazing job y'all!

Good eats in Temecula. We went in on a pizza craving and decided for an 18 inch Pie; Half Tropical Hawaiian, Half Pepperoni. So light & delicious. I would recommend to get it fresh out the oven for that full cheesy/saucy effect, If you opt for a slice maybe ask if they can throw it in the oven for a few minutes that way you can enjoy it properly. As far as service goes I would like to render a shoutout to the guys working there; so polite and so sweet. I loved their service. We would've dined in the calm ambience but it was so nice out, we ended up heading to a nearby park and enjoyed our NY pizza under the sun rays. Yeayyy :D overall awesome experience.

This is the best pizza in Temecula! I'm from NY and this is the closest you will find here, The crust is perfect and this pizza has the right amount of sauce and cheese and a large variety of toppings to choose from, before this my go to was flippin pizza used to be but they recently changed their ingredients and bongionos is good too, but this is a little bit better.

Times Square Pizza and Bagel in Temecula is our top choice for pizza. Whether you want traditional slices or one of their signature creations, their pizza is always delicious. Their ranch dressing is exceptional and a perfect complement to any slice. We usually share the 2-slice combo, but sometimes we each get our own if we're especially hungry. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere feels like a true local gem. If you're in Temecula and looking for great pizza, this is the place to visit.

Honestly tried Times Square 2 years ago and wasn't a fan but wanted to give a small business another chance. Good thing we did! This time we ordered the Brooklyn pizza (Wednesday 7/17) and the crust and dough had the perfect chew. The mistake I made 2 years ago, which I should have known better, was I ordered the works pizza which had a lot of ingredients but makes the pizza bottom soggy. Especially when it was to go and not eaten there. The Brooklyn pizza has just enough toppings and was delicious. The next time we go we will eat the pizza there. The customer service was great from the young lady who took the order and also to the young man making the pizza. He also rang me up when I picked up the order. The service alone would make me go back so keep up the great work!

Got a NY white pizza today. Crust was nice and thin, cheese ratio was good and the flavor of the sauce was on point. All in all, it would be comparable to most NY pizza- happy to find it here locally. We got take out - service was polite and prompt. Pizza was ready on time. Place looks like a standard pizza place in a strip mall, wouldn't mind sitting here and enjoying a slice some day but for now, Friday night, pizza and tv hit the spot!

I highly recommend this place if you're craving New York Pizza. We ordered the pizza through DoorDash and the pizza was delivered within a good time. The price for two 18" XXL pizzas (NY Pesto Amore and NY Pepperoni) with tip was around $70. The price is definitely more than Dominoes or Little Caesars, but it is delicious! I just wish it was more affordable. I meant to take a picture of both pizzas but they went fast!